top of page

What rules are we playing? What do your words mean?

12 hours ago
4 min read
chess board with a time machine and a bishop in along scarf requesting "Can I take that back please"

Can we talk games, please? Language. Dynamics.

Ambiguity, anyone?


I'll go first.


I was playing chess online yesterday.


I'm not great at it.


I mean, I have my moments, but still, there are times when someone else's blunder is a bit of a godsend.


Sorry, yes, I know that's not very nice of me. Someone Else's Blunder. It's not really something to celebrate is it?


I mean, what would Jesus do — if He was playing chess?


(Hmm. Well, I may be thinking of Jonathan Roumie right now, rather than actual Jesus, but in chess, someone else's blunder — well, that's kind of the game isn't it?)


Oops.


aHA!!


Well played, Sir.


[Handshake as Jonathan Roumie shrugs and winks, and we remember his Jesus persona is also intentionally rubbish at ballgames…]



I digress.


Back to yesterday. Or rather first of all, the day before yesterday.


On that day a different opponent of mine experienced just such a blunder, in my favour.


On that occasion, I received a little haptic rumble on my watch and a visual alert on my phone, which I clicked to read.


"Can I take that move back, please?"

appealed the blunderer.


I smiled to myself, with the kind of performance incredulity my father used to reserve for split infinitives.


TAKE — IT — BACK???


Why, I remember the days when even an accidental nudge of your sleeve on a pawn was binding unless you'd first announced in French!


"Please?"


Pleading now. Oh, what the heck…


I let them.


And then of course,

they went on to win, because —


this is exactly why

I always make that mental note:


Never EVER let them take a move back because you'll only find yourself unable to take back the moves you'll inevitably make as a result, and then — who can you blame?


The same kind of thing happens when you actually win a game.


Just as you're basking in glorious relief, they ask for a friendly rematch.


Listen: Just. Say. No.

It's never going to end well. For me, at least.


And that's only partly because of my mediocre chess skill.


It's mostly because on an average day a casual and inconsequential game of chess offers a tiny entertaining lift. A quick five minute, ten minute distraction, a bit like a wordle or a nine letter anagram to untangle for fun.


But the moment it ramps up into a revenge match,

or the defence of an unbeaten record,

or something more significant,


all my competitive spirit starts floundering like a dying fly in a glass of wine.


I have to put myself out of my misery at that point.

Have a cup of tea instead.


(NB. Do not put me on your chess team unless it's just for a window display or an undercover mission or something.)


Anyway. That was what happened the day before yesterday.


And then yesterday itself, another such blunder was followed by a similar request.



"Your opponent requests a take back of their last move."



This time I ignored it.


I mean, that's the plan isn't it? The wiser option?


I didn't exactly say no. I just carried on, like in the old days — the days when I didn't know how to access that part of the app anyway so it was a bit of a moot point. Back then I didn't know about takebacks. Frankly, those days were bliss…


I ignored it and made my next move as usual. This is chess, after all, not time travel.



"Thanks."



What's that?


(My opponent. For some reason, their response was, "Thanks.")


The thing is, I'm still really not quite sure what happened. Sarcasm? Or — as I suspect — the move I made subsequently was itself a blunder, but now on my side… (still sarcasm in that case tbh)


but, wait… if —

my mind wasn't on —

all the subtext,

and I wasn't really…


— I mean… thanks?


THANKS?!


Hmm.


Surely, I was being taunted at the doorway of someone else's personal drama.


As well as my own.


I mean. It's one thing having to navigate the trip wires on the chess board itself, but here we are now ALSO apparently required to contend with the kind of poker tactics I used to hate in junior league chess matches in the eighties…


(Someone forgot the chess clock. I found myself sitting at the board for — an hour? — between moves. I literally thought that, as it was an under 18s match, I was contractually obliged to sit it out however long it took. Fearing for my life, I threw in the towel and went off in tears to watch Fraggle Rock.)


Decades later I had hoped online chess with the social elements turned off might be slightly less ad hominem.


But, Thanks?


Was this passive aggression or strategic mind games?


And is there a difference?


I was now so intensely focussed on areas of life and existence and projection that it was impossible to simply play without channelling Mitchell, Coren Mitchell and Oliver all at once.


So of course, I wrote back.


I did, yes.


Subtly at first.


Just,



"?"



And then,


(in case my planned imminent mercy resignation needed a suicide note or perhaps a short eulogy) —



"what rules are we playing?

what do your words mean?"



And then, fair reader,



I resigned.



(sociolinguistic mic drop)

bottom of page